Records View

A Randomized, prospective, multicenter trial of 3d printing, a patient-specific surgical guide for breast-conserving surgery after neoadjuvant chemotherapy: comparative evaluation according to the presence or absence of surgical guide.

Status Approved

  • First Submitted Date

    2019/11/07

  • Registered Date

    2019/11/25

  • Last Updated Date

    2023/06/12

CRIS Required

WHO ICTRP (International Clinical Trial Registry Platform) Required

  • 1. Background

    Background - CRIS Registration Number, Unique Protocol ID, Public/Brief Title, Scientific Title, Acronym, MFDS Regulated Study, IND/IDE Protocol, Registered at Other Registry, Name of Registry/Registration Number
    CRIS
    Registration Number
    KCT0004469
    Unique Protocol ID 2019-1225
    Public/Brief Title A randomized, prospective, multicenter study to validate the usefulness of 3D-printing surgical guides for breast-conserving surgery in breast cancer patients treated with neoadjuvant chemotherapy
    Scientific Title A Randomized, prospective, multicenter trial of 3d printing, a patient-specific surgical guide for breast-conserving surgery after neoadjuvant chemotherapy: comparative evaluation according to the presence or absence of surgical guide.
    Acronym 3D BTS
    MFDS Regulated Study No
    IND/IDE Protocol Yes
    Registered at Other Registry No
    Healthcare Benefit Approval Status Submitted pending
  • 2. Institutional Review Board / Ethics Committee

    Institutional Review Board Information
    Board Approval Status Submitted approval
    Board Approval Number 2019-1225
    Approval Date 2019-09-26
    Institutional Review Board Name Asan Medical Center Institutional Review Board
    Institutional Review Board Address 88, Olympic-ro 43-gil, Songpa-gu, Seoul
    Institutional Review Board Telephone 02-3010-7166
    Data Monitoring Committee No
  • 3. Contact Details

    Contact Details Information - Contact Person for Principal Investigator / Scientific Queries, Contact Person for Public Queries, Contact Person for Updating Information의 Name, Title, Email, Telephone, Cellular Phone, Affiliation, Address
    Contact Person for Principal Investigator / Scientific Queries
    Name BeomSeok Ko
    Title associate professor
    Telephone +82-2-3010-3480
    Affiliation Asan Medical Center
    Address 88, Olympic-ro 43-gil, Songpa-gu, Seoul
    Contact Person for Public Queries
    Name Munju Jeong
    Title CRC
    Telephone +82-2-3010-6194
    Affiliation Asan Medical Center
    Address 88, Olympic-ro 43-gil, Songpa-gu, Seoul
    Contact Person for Updating Information
    Name BeomSeok Ko
    Title associate professor
    Telephone +82-2-3010-3480
    Affiliation Asan Medical Center
    Address 88, Olympic-ro 43-gil, Songpa-gu, Seoul
  • 4. Status

    Status Information - Study Site, Overall Recruitment Status, Date of First Enrollment, Status of First Enrollment, Target Number of Participant, Primary Completion Date, Recruitment Status by Participating Study Site, Name of Study Site, Recruitment Status, Date of First Enrollment, Status of First Enrollemnt
    Study Site Multi-center Number of center : 4
    Overall Recruitment Status Completed
    Date of First Enrollment 2019-12-09 Actual
    Target Number of Participant 488
    Primary Completion Date 2021-11-04 , Actual
    Study Completion Date 2021-11-17 , Actual
    Recruitment Status by Participating Study Site 1
    Name of Study Yonsei University Health System, Severance Hospital
    Recruitment Status Completed
    Date of First Enrollment 2019-12-09 ,
    Recruitment Status by Participating Study Site 2
    Name of Study Samsung Medical Center
    Recruitment Status Completed
    Date of First Enrollment 2020-04-29 ,
    Recruitment Status by Participating Study Site 3
    Name of Study Seoul National University Hospital
    Recruitment Status Completed
    Date of First Enrollment 2020-02-11 ,
    Recruitment Status by Participating Study Site 4
    Name of Study Asan Medical Center
    Recruitment Status Completed
    Date of First Enrollment 2020-01-06 ,
  • 5. Source of Monetary / Material Support

    Source of Monetary / Material Support Information - Organization Name, Organization Type, Project ID
    1. Source of Monetary/Material Support
    Organization Name Korea Institute for Advancement of Technology
    Organization Type Government
    Project ID P0008801
  • 6. Sponsor Organization

    Sponsor Organization Information - Organization Name, Organization Type
    1. Sponsor Organization
    Organization Name Asan Medical Center
    Organization Type Medical Institute
  • 7. Study Summary

    Study Summary Information
    Lay Summary
    Research Purpose: 
    To compare the clinical efficacy of conventional targeting methods vs. customized 3D printing surgical guide for breast-conserving surgery after neoadjuvant chemotherapy, which is made patient specific based on MRI. 
    
    Research Background: 
    If the tumor size is large in breast cancer patients, the possibility of conserving the breasts by reducing the size of breast cancer by performing the neoadjuvant chemotherapy is increasing. It is important to know the exact area of residual cancer for complete resection of the tumor during partial resection after neoadjuvant systemic therapy. Accurate area marking was difficult. Usually, the tumor is marked by ultrasound or mammography guide H-wire insertion to confirm the location of the tumor before surgery, but there are several limitations.
    
    1) Neoadjuvant systemic therapy (NST) 
    Neoadjuvant systemic therapy in breast patients has the advantage of being able to see the effect of treatment in advance, and it is possible to reduce the size of the tumor so that it can be operated in patients who cannot operate or switch from total mastectomy to partial resection. 
    
    2) Breast MRI 
    MRI is the most accurate imaging method for predicting areas of breast cancer. In particular, it has good accuracy in predicting the area of residual cancer after NST. However, conventional targeting methods make it difficult to quantitatively mark the area of the tumor observed in MRI.
    Problem 
    * MRI posture differs from surgical posture
    -For accurate diagnosis, breast MRI is performed in the prone position using a breast coil. 
    -Since surgery is performed in supine position, compared with the lesion location determined by prone MRI, there is a constant deviation due to breast deformation, which makes it difficult to accurately determine the location of the lesion during surgery.
    
    3) Breast Conserving Surgery (BCS) 
    The positive resection margin should lead to recurrence, so that the area of the tumor should be accurately identified before surgery to remove it precisely so that there is no tumor at the margin. Completely remove the tumor but preserve normal tissue as much as possible for cosmetic results. 
    
    Problems with conventional targeting methods
    -Difficulty in marking the area of the tumor on the MRI in the breast
    Cannot quantitatively mark tumor areas
    -It is difficult to know the original tumor area before treatment
    -Causing pain in patients
    -The procedure takes time
    -Deviation occurs according to the operator
    
    In order to solve these problems, we have developed a patient customized 3D printing breast surgery guide (3DP-BSG) that can display the tumor range using MRI information before and after treatment. we wants to check the accuracy and usefulness of 3DP-BSG in BCS after NST.
  • 8. Study Design

    Study Design Information - Study Type, Study Purpose, Phase, Intervention Model, Blinding/Masking, Blinded Subject, Allocation, Intervention Type, Intervention Description, Number of Arms, Arm Label, Target Number of Participant, Arm Type, Arm Description
    Study Type Interventional Study
    Study Purpose
    Treatment
    Phase Phase2
    Intervention Model Parallel  
    Blinding/Masking Open
    Allocation RCT
    Intervention Type Medical Device  
    Intervention Description
    The experimental group applies the 3D printing breast surgery guide (3DP-BSG). 3DP-BSG is prepared based on pre- and post-treatment medical images (MRI / CT) in patients undergoing neoadjuvant chemotherapy. In breast-conserving surgery, 3DP-BSG is used to target tumors.
    Number of Arms 2
    Arm 1

    Arm Label

    control group: Surgery using conventional targeting methods

    Target Number of Participant

    244

    Arm Type

    Others

    Arm Description

    * Control group: Standard treatment of surgical method using the conventional targeting method
    ①  To mark the area of the tumor before surgery, mammography or ultrasound guide hook wire and skin marking are performed according to the determination of the concentration.
    ②  After removing the tumor along the marked area, check several surrounding margins for remaining tumors through frozen section analysis to determining further resection.
    ③  After the hemostasis, check that there is no bleeding and complete the surgery.
    Adverse events are recorded when there are new signs/symptoms or deterioration of underlying diseases after random assignment.
    The investigator satisfaction survey is completed
    Arm 2

    Arm Label

    Experimental group: Surgery with 3D Printing Breast Surgery Guide (3DP-BSG)

    Target Number of Participant

    244

    Arm Type

    Experimental

    Arm Description

    Test group: Apply 3D printing breast surgery guide (3DP-BSG)
    ① Surgical guide is produced by 3D printing to target the tumor by 3D modeling breast and tumor using neoadjuvant before and after medical images (MRI, CT)
    Place the 3DP-BSG on the breast surface using the body landmarks (top end point of the sternum and the corresponding side / opposite papilla) before surgery
    ③ Mark the area of the tumor on the surface of the breast using 3DP-BSG and inject the blue-dye using a syringe along the guide column to indicate the extent of resection around the tumor.
    ④ After removing the tumor along the markings on the skin outside / inside the breast, check the presence of residual cancer through the cryosection test in several areas of the marginal resection to determine whether to further resection.
    ⑤ After the hemostasis check that there is no bleeding and finish the operation.
  • 9. Subject Eligibility

    Subject Eligibility Information
    Condition(s)/Problem(s) * (C00-D48)Neoplasms 
       (C50.99)Malignant neoplasm of breast unspecified, unspecified side 

    invasive breast neoplasms
    Rare Disease No
    Inclusion Criteria

    Gender

    Female

    Age

    20Year~79Year

    Description

    •Female patients from 20 to 79  years of age 
    •Patients who received or is receiving neoadjuvant chemotherapy, after diagnosed with invasive breast cancer by histology
    •Patients who are scheduled to have breast-conserving surgery after neoadjuvant chemotherapy 
    •Subjects who fully understands and agrees in writing to the Informed consent form
    Exclusion Criteria
    • Patients who have contraindications of MRI
     ① Those with an inserted electrical device, clip for the prevention of aneurysm, artificial of metallic material around the eyeball
     ② Patients who have Claustrophobia
     ③ Patients with difficulty using gadolinium-based angiography - severe allergic or impaired of kidney function (creatinine > 2.0) 
     ④ Pregnant
    • Difficult partial resection due to large calcification lesions
    • Patients deemed unsuitable to participate in this clinical trial at the Investigator's discretion
    Healthy Volunteers No
  • 10. Outcome Measure(s)

    Outcome Measure(s) Information - Type of Primary Outcome, Primary Outcome, Outcome, Timepoint, Secondary Outcome, Outcome, Timepoint
    Type of Primary Outcome Safety
    Primary Outcome(s) 1
    Outcome
    Tumor at first resection margin
    Timepoint
    During surgery
    Secondary Outcome(s) 1
    Outcome
    Distance from tumor to edge of specimen
    Timepoint
    Postoperative pathology examination
    Secondary Outcome(s) 2
    Outcome
    Volume of the removed specimen
    Timepoint
    Postoperative pathology examination
    Secondary Outcome(s) 3
    Outcome
    Weight of removed specimen
    Timepoint
    Postoperative pathology examination
    Secondary Outcome(s) 4
    Outcome
    Surgery time
    Timepoint
    During surgery
    Secondary Outcome(s) 5
    Outcome
    Patient satisfaction
    Timepoint
    Outpatient visit after surgery (2 weeks after surgery +/- 7 days)
    Secondary Outcome(s) 6
    Outcome
    Surgeon's Satisfaction
    Timepoint
    Within 7 days after surgery
  • 11. Study Results and Publication

    Study Results and Publication Information - Result Registered, Final Enrollment Number, Number of Publication, Publications, Results Upload, Date of Posting Results, Protocol URL or File Upload, Brief Summary
    Result Registered No
  • 12. Sharing of Study Data(Deidentified Individual-Patient Data, IPD)

    Sharing of Study Data Information - Sharing Statement, Time of Sharing, Way of Sharing
    Sharing Statement Yes
    Time of Sharing 2022. 12
    Way of Sharing Available on Request
    (spdoctorko@gmail.com)
화면 최상단으로 이동

TOP

BOTTOM

화면 최하단으로 이동